Fake HIV medication reached U.S. pharmacies—and patients
Gilead Sciences filed an amended complaint in September 2022.
PSM was concerned when Janssen Pharmaceuticals and Gilead Sciences warned in December 2020 and August 2021 that counterfeits of several HIV medications had been discovered circulating in the United States.
Then, in January 2022, the Wall Street Journal broke an astonishing story: Gilead Sciences was suing a ring of drug sellers and distributors that allegedly sold 85,247 of the counterfeit bottles worth more than $250 million to U.S. pharmacies.
The suit accuses a complex network of companies and individuals of selling these fake and diverted medications into U.S. pharmacies using forged track and trace documents. Patients of these pharmacies were given used, resealed bottles that contained the wrong HIV treatment, over-the-counter painkillers, actual pebbles, or an antipsychotic that rendered one patient unable to walk or speak.
On June 17, 2024, Gilead Sciences sued a second network of individuals and companies for allegedly selling used bottles of its prescription HIV medicine in New York and New Jersey pharmacies, sometimes with the wrong medicine inside them.
Gilead’s complaint alleges that this ring was led by Peter Khaim, a convicted criminal named in the company’s July 2021 lawsuit. Gilead’s defendants also include convicted black market drug trafficker Boris Aminov and several of his co-defendants.
Timeline of Events
December 2020: Janssen Pharmaceutical warns that counterfeit Symtuza has been distributed to three U.S. pharmacies.
August 2021: Gilead Sciences warns about fake Biktarvy and Descovy circulating in the U.S.
July 2021: Gilead Sciences files a complaint against a network of drug distributors it says are selling counterfeit versions of several of its HIV medicines. (Read the current complaint.)
April 2022: Janssen filed suit against some of the same distributors
June 17, 2022: The Department of Justice filed criminal charges against a related HIV drug diversion ring in Florida
September 2022: Gilead Sciences added over 50 additional defendants to the case and identified two kingpins in the scheme, one of whom is the man the Department of Justice indicted in June 2022.
June 2023: Miami resident Lazaro Hernandez, who had been indicted in June 2022 and identified as a kingpin in September 2022, was sentenced to 15 years in prison.
December 2023: Armando Herrera received a four-year-and-three-month prison sentence.
February 2024: Safe Chain Solutions settled with Gilead Sciences for $2.7 million.
June 2024: Gilead Sciences sued a second network of individuals and companies for allegedly selling used bottles of its prescription HIV medicine. Read the complaint.
Want to know more? Click the thumbnails below to watch our videos.
August 16, 2021: Fake HIV Meds in the U.S.
Counterfeit versions of Biktarvy, Descovy, and Symtuza were found in U.S. pharmacies at the end of 2020 and in 2021.
These specialty drugs have a very limited number of authorized distributors. The authorized distributors for Biktarvy and Descovy can be found here, and the authorized distributors for Symtuza can be found here.
Purchasing medication from unauthorized wholesalers and distributors puts patients at risk.
Pharmacists: if you receive a suspicious offer for a specialty drug from a company, please immediately contact the FDA's Office of Criminal Investigations at DrugSupplyChainIntegrity@fda.hhs.gov or 1-800-551-3989. Please spread the word by sharing the above video with other pharmacists.
Patients: if you have concerns the medicine you have is not genuine, please contact the manufacturer immediately as well as the FDA's Office of Criminal Investigations at DrugSupplyChainIntegrity@fda.hhs.gov or 1-800-551-3989.
February 2, 2022: Fake HIV Drug Ring
The Wall Street Journal published a story about the counterfeiting ring selling fake versions of HIV medications to licensed pharmacies in January 2022. We learned that
- 85,247 of bottles of counterfeit Gilead product worth $250mm were discovered;
- The ring's activity spanned nine states and sixteen locations;
- Companies selling the products falsified transaction records which in some cases, revealed the crime; and
- In one case the fake product was caught by a patient after it evaded detection by a pharmacist.
There are a number of things to learn from the pharmacists that were duped by these criminal wholesalers:
Fake sale logs: The criminal wholesalers were required to provide sale transaction documentation as required by the Drug Supply Chain Security Act. The transaction logs given to the pharmacies were faked to show the medicine passed through well known major wholesalers. (It did not.) Gilead’s Brand Protection / Product Quality department has stated that they will check a transaction log on any purchase for a pharmacy. Check with them before you purchase.
Real bottles, fake medicine: The criminal wholesalers used real bottles purchased illegally from patients in order to get real serialization numbers, filled them with counterfeits, and sealed them incorrectly with their own foil. Alert pharmacists might have been able to spot these fakes.
Unauthorized wholesalers: All three of these products have limited wholesalers authorized by the manufacturer to sell them, and the criminal wholesalers involved are not on these lists. Don’t buy from wholesalers not authorized by Janssen or Gilead.
What you can do: The common thread in these cases is that pharmacies were offered prices lower than the major, authorized distributors who have access to the very best pricing. Pharmacists should be wary of any medication with a steep discount better than the one their own wholesaler offers, even if it comes from another licensed pharmacy. If you have any doubts, always consult the company’s brand protection team or the FDA’s Office of Criminal Investigation.
June 29, 2022: Fraudsters in Court
In June 2022, the Justice Department unsealed another HIV medicine trafficking case, alleging that a Miami man distributed $230 million in illegally acquired HIV medicines, as well as cancer and psychiatric drugs. In September 2022, Gilead Sciences' identified this man as a major organizer of the counterfeiting ring that is at the center of their lawsuit.
In these diversion schemes, the criminals acquire medicine illegally through Medicaid fraud or street collection operations and then take that already-dispensed medicine and sell it back into the supply chain.
They partner with criminal wholesalers who forge labels and documents to make them look legitimate—to unwitting distributors and pharmacies which is how they reach unsuspecting patients who literally rely on the integrity of these medicines to keep them alive.
Once a medicine has been diverted, it’s not safe to take. Nothing can stop ALL these schemes, but the Drug Supply Chain Security Act is making it harder for criminals to pull this off without getting caught.
If you’re a pharmacist, consult our pharmacists page for resources to help educate you about the DSCSA and how it can help you protect your patients.
If you’re a patient concerned about your medication, check out this PSA by HIV survivor Brandon Macsata about how you might be able to spot a counterfeit, even if it sneaks past your pharmacist.
October 19, 2022: Fake Drug Kingpins Found
In September 2022, Gilead Science filed an amended complaint that offered more insight into the details of the alleged counterfeiting operation. The new document
- Raised the total number of defendants to more than 140 expanded the operation's footprint to 13 states.
- Revealed that Gilead's lawsuit hasn't entirely stopped the operation: amended complaint says that a new company sold 1,000 bottles to a pharmacy just this year.
- Identified two Florida men as the kingpins of the scheme.
These men, one of whom is already under indictment, allegedly managed street collectors, fake wholesalers, and licensed distributors who sold fakes to pharmacies. They ran the entire operation on prepaid burner cell phones using the pseudonyms “Rob” and “Thomas.” Even their fellow defendants didn’t know who they were. Gilead’s investigators found them by matching their phones’ geolocation data to names on flight records.
January 17, 2024: Pharma Catches HIV Scammer
This summer, high stakes poker player Lazaro Hernandez got 15 years in federal prison for a whole other game: His counterfeiting ring collected tens of thousands of bottles of HIV drugs from patients and used licensed wholesalers in multiple states to sell them back to U.S. pharmacies at a discount.
A lot of what we know about this ring comes from Gilead Sciences, which filed a lawsuit against hundreds of people involved in 2021. Their anti counterfeiting team provided information that helped federal prosecutors to build a criminal case against Hernandez.
We don’t often think about these teams, but they monitor international markets for counterfeiters and collect evidence through undercover purchases and product testing, and they protect patients by protecting the integrity of our medicines.
Report it to them if you find anything suspicious about your medicine by contacting the manufacturer. You’ll find phone numbers for complaints and for reporting adverse events on their websites. In the meantime, keep up with cases like these at safemedicines.org.
April 3, 2024: Safe Chain Settles Unsafe Med Case
A settlement agreement between Safe Chain Solutions and Gilead Science has closed a chapter in one of the biggest counterfeiting cases in years.
Safe Chain is prohibited from importing, purchasing, selling, distributing, or marketing Gilead products, and prohibited from helping anyone else to do that either.
They have agreed to be audited by an independent firm annually for any evidence they violated this agreement.
If they violate the prohibition they're liable for damages for 100 times the wholesale acquisition cost of the product: A single $3 ,000 bottle of Gilead's HIV medication would mean a penalty of $300 ,000.
Finally, the company and the Boyd Brothers forfeit $2 .7 million in cash, investments, and life insurance products.
This is a victory for Gilead Sciences and their outside counsel Patterson Belknap, who mounted a huge investigation in order to file civil charges under the Lanham Act.
Fake HIV meds in the news
- Gilead alleges drug counterfeiting operation at NYC pharmaciesAugust 16, 2024
- Owners of Cambridge pharmaceutical distributor indicted in illicit HIV medication scheme | Latest News | wboc.comJune 27, 2024
- Southern District of New York | Leader of black-market HIV medication fraud scheme sentenced to nine years in prison | United States Department of JusticeApril 17, 2024
- Southern District of New York | Pharmacy owner sentenced to four years in prison for health care fraud | United States Department of JusticeApril 18, 2024
- Man Sentenced for Illegally Distributing Over $16M of Adulterated HIV MedicationDecember 21, 2023
- Northern District of California | Northridge man sentenced to 33 months in prison for sales of black market drugs to unsuspecting prescription drug customers | United States Department of JusticeMarch 24, 2021
- Leader of black-market HIV medication fraud scheme pleads guiltyDecember 11, 2023
- Fraud in a bottle: Big Pharma takes on counterfeit drugsDecember 11, 2023
- Authorities warn that fake HIV drugs are found in Kenya despite a crackdown on counterfeitsNovember 22, 2023
- FBI busts 16-million dollar fake HIV drug schemeNovember 7, 2023
See older news about counterfeit and diverted HIV drugs on our pinboard.